Skip to content

Selling at Christmas Without Black Friday or Discounts, Betting on the Fair Price

Just skipping Black Friday isn't enough, or you'll hit the November slump where customers wait. Announce your no discount stance early, double loyalty points to pull sales forward, prep your stores to handle the rush, and cut through the paid noise with a drive-to-store angle.

Author
Axel Corton
Subject
Strategy
Date
Read time
6 min
Selling at Christmas Without Black Friday or Discounts, Betting on the Fair Price

Key takeaways

  • No promos, no Black Friday, ever, to defend fair pricing year round and protect the margin.
  • Announcing the no discount policy early in November removes doubt and unlocks the purchase right away.
  • Loyalty points doubled all November to pull sales forward without touching the listed price.
  • A second register per store and 7 day opening from the Sunday after Black Friday to absorb the peak.
  • Four drive-to-store videos on emotional angles, only the outro changes with the local store address.

We work with a retail brand, a group of concept stores selling emerging, responsible designers. Their whole thing from day one has been breaking away from a kind of commerce that lost its soul. And in that soulless commerce, there's one big culprit in their eyes, the discount. The endless markdowns that leave customers with no clue what a product's fair price actually is.

So the call was made, owned, non-negotiable. No discounts. No Black Friday. Ever. You pull people in with the product and the in-store experience, not with the price.

Except come November, you've got a problem. And it's not the one you'd expect.

The dip nobody sees coming

When every other brand is screaming -30% for a month straight, your customers start hesitating. The in-store observation was crystal clear, some customers wait until the BFCM sale is over to buy. Not because they're hoping for a discount from you, but because they want to be sure they're not missing a deal somewhere else. When in doubt, they stall.

The result is that you create an anticipation dip. Everyone waits. Your Black Friday weekend, while everyone else is having their biggest day of the year, you've got a half-empty store because people went off hunting discounts elsewhere.

That's where a lot of brands that refuse discounts fall flat. They think it's enough to just not run Black Friday. It isn't. If you do nothing, you eat the dip. You're fighting the rest of the market with no weapons.

Communicate the no-Black-Friday, don't just avoid it

The single most important thing we put in place was saying it clearly and early. From November onward, we communicate that there'll be no Black Friday and no discounts. Not in a combative way, not to dunk on anyone else. Just to kill the doubt.

Because the customer who's hesitating, the one waiting until the end of the period to buy, what are they really waiting for? They're waiting for the information. If you tell them in black and white that there won't be a better offer in three weeks, that there's no catch, you unlock the purchase right away. You turn their wait-and-see into a decision.

It's a bit counterintuitive. Your instinct is to stay quiet about the fact that you don't run discounts, to not make a big deal of it. When the exact opposite is what you should do. Your lack of markdowns is an argument. A fair price all year round is a promise. But you still have to say it out loud.

If you want to dig into the pricing and margin logic behind this approach, we covered it elsewhere in how to set an ad budget from your margin, not your revenue.

Double loyalty points instead of cutting prices

Now, telling people to buy without giving them a reason to do it early doesn't always cut it. You need a lever to get them in during November rather than December. And above all, that lever can't touch the price.

What we did was double loyalty program points for the entire month of November.

There's a double logic here. First, it gives a real reason to buy now rather than wait. You earn twice the points, it's concrete, it's a time-limited perk, but it doesn't hurt your displayed price. The product stays at the same rate, your margin stays intact. You're simply rewarding loyalty.

Second, and this is almost as important, it spreads out the sales. December in these stores is hell. Packed, lines, people wanting their gifts wrapped. If you can shift some of the sales into November, you decongest December. You sell just as much, but without your teams being swamped and without the customer experience falling apart at the worst possible moment.

It's a way to steer the flow without ever touching the price. Exactly the brand's philosophy.

Prep the store to ring it up, literally

Something that gets overlooked way too often when we talk about Christmas is the pure operations side. You can have the best campaign in the world, but if your checkout is a bottleneck, you lose sales and you degrade the experience.

Two simple moves on this front.

A second register per store, so people wait less when it's time to pay. Sounds trivial, but a ten-minute line on a December Saturday means baskets abandoned on the spot, people putting the item back and walking out.

And opening 7 days a week starting the Sunday after Black Friday. You open wider to absorb the peak instead of cramming it into two or three days.

This part isn't sexy, it doesn't make anyone dream. But a brand betting everything on the in-store experience has no right to leave a customer stuck at the register. In-store service is like the salesperson on the floor, if checkout jams up, the whole experience collapses at the very last second.

On the ads side, Black Friday raises a real question. It's the time of year when everyone communicates the most. Brands, influencers, everyone piles onto placements. More competition means auctions climb hard. You pay way more per click for a message that, on top of that, struggles to break through the noise.

Two options. Either you pause media during the most expensive stretch, you stop fighting discount budgets you don't have, and you come back right after when the auctions drop. Or you stay present, but on a completely different angle from everyone else. While the others are shouting -40%, you're talking about something else.

On the creative side, that's exactly what we built. Four distinct videos tackling Christmas from different angles. The hunt for the gift, the care put into the wrapping, that kind of thing. The goal is drive-to-store, getting people into the shops. And the only local variation is the outro, with the storefront and the address of the relevant location. The rest of the film is identical everywhere.

Building your creative around drive-to-store rather than discount mechanically pulls you out of the price war. You're communicating on an emotion, on an experience, not on a percentage. And over a period where everyone's saying the same thing, talking about something else is the only way not to drown. If you want angles to run your phases cleanly without ending up with a hole in the funnel, I covered it in Black Friday in tiers.

Is it worth refusing discounts

I'll be straight with you. Running Black Friday is easier. You slash prices, the crowds show up, you post a big number over one weekend. Refusing discounts is harder in the short term, and it forces you to work every lever above at the same time.

But there's an underlying calculation. If you run sales, it means you margin less across your year. Isn't it better to have the fair price all year round, the one that removes the price friction without ever needing to slash, rather than inflating your price so you can cut it later. For a brand whose entire reason for existing is the fair price, the answer is obvious. Consistency pays over time.

The real danger isn't refusing Black Friday. It's refusing it without putting anything in its place. If you just say no to discounts and do nothing else, you take the November dip right in the face.

What works is the opposite. You say loud and clear that you have no discounts to kill the doubt. You give a reason to buy early with doubled loyalty points. You prep your stores to handle the flow. And you break out of the paid noise with an angle that's yours. Do those four things and your discount-free Christmas holds up.

Frequently asked questions

I refuse to run Black Friday, but I'm losing sales in November. Normal?

Yes, that's the anticipation dip. Your customers wait until the period ends to be sure they're not missing something elsewhere. The fix is to communicate clearly from November that you'll have no Black Friday and no discounts. You kill the doubt and unlock the purchase right away.

How do I get people to buy in November without cutting my prices?

Double the points on your loyalty program for the month of November. You give a real reason to buy early, a time-limited perk, without ever touching the displayed price. Bonus, it spreads out sales and decongests December.

Should I cut my ads during Black Friday?

Two options. Either you pause during the stretch when auctions explode and come back right after. Or you stay present but on a totally different angle from everyone else, drive-to-store instead of discount, so you don't drown in the noise.

Fair price all year or inflated price I can slash in sales?

If you run sales, you margin less across the year. The fair price removes the price friction without ever having to slash. For a brand whose whole reason for being is that, it's more consistent and it pays over time.

What should I watch out for in-store during the Christmas peak?

Checkout. Add a second register per store and open wider, say 7 days a week starting the Sunday after Black Friday. A ten-minute line on a December Saturday means baskets put back on the spot and people walking out.

About the author

Test photo, to be replaced by the portrait of Axel Corton

Axel CortonFounderLinkedIn

Keep reading

Subscribe to our newsletter

Our methods on paid media, eCommerce and CRM, in your inbox.

Opening soon